AI vs Human Agents: Cost Breakdown

February 24, 2025
February 24, 2025

AI is changing customer service by cutting costs. Here's the key takeaway: AI interactions cost $0.03–$0.25 per minute, while human agents cost $3.00–$6.50 per minute. This dramatic difference has led 80% of businesses to adopt or plan AI chatbot (or AI Agent) use by 2025. Companies using AI report a 35% drop in costs and a 32% revenue boost.

Quick Overview:

  • Human Agent Costs:
    • $110,000/year per agent (salary + benefits).
    • $8.01 per customer interaction.
    • High turnover adds training and hiring costs.
  • AI Costs:
    • $300–$500/month for basic SaaS tools.
    • $0.10 per customer interaction.
    • One-time setup fees for advanced systems ($3,000–$100,000).

Key Insight: AI handles routine tasks at lower costs, while humans focus on more complex issues. A hybrid model maximizes efficiency and cost savings, resulting in AI saving businesses millions, whilst cutting response times significantly.

Cost Factor AI Human Agents
Cost per Minute $0.03–$0.25 $3.00–$6.50
Annual Cost (Per Agent) $3,600–$6,000 (SaaS) $110,000
Response Times Instant (24/7) Varies
Turnover Costs None High

AI's cost-effectiveness is clear, but blending AI with human expertise offers the best results.

AI Chatbots vs Human Customer Service: Comparing Performance and Efficiency

Cost Elements in Support Operations

Let’s break down the main cost factors involved in running AI and human support operations. These include staff-related expenses, AI system costs, and shared infrastructure.

Staff Expenses

Hiring and maintaining a customer support representative costs around $110,000 per year. This figure includes:

  • Base salary: Typically ranges from $50,000 to $70,000 for entry-level roles.
  • Benefits and taxes: Healthcare, retirement contributions, and other mandatory costs.
  • Paid time off: Vacation, sick leave, and other time-off policies.
  • Equipment and workspace: Computers, desks, and office utilities.

High turnover rates - reaching up to 30% - also add recruitment and training costs, putting further strain on budgets.

AI System Expenses

AI-based solutions come with their own set of expenses, focusing on technology rather than personnel. Key cost components include:

Cost Component Typical Range Key Details
SaaS Subscription $300-$500/month Covers basic platform access.
Advanced Solutions $1,000-$10,000+/month Offers scalability and advanced features.
Data Processing Variable Often billed separately from subscriptions.
Implementation One-time cost Includes setup and integration.

"Implementing AI isn't just a simple matter of replacing humans and cutting costs. Yes, you should use AI. And yes, you will save money. But the path to success and the economics of how it works is nuanced." - Jon Tucker, CEO HelpFlow

Shared Costs

Both AI systems and human teams rely on shared infrastructure, though their usage differs:

  • Communication Platforms: Human teams require coverage during business hours, while AI operates 24/7 without extra costs.
  • CRM Systems: Customer relationship management tools are essential for both, but AI can streamline these by handling 70-80% of routine queries.
  • Quality Monitoring: Human teams need supervisors and quality assurance staff, whereas AI requires ongoing tuning and performance checks.

The industry is moving toward integrated solutions, with helpdesks increasingly embedding AI features. Some businesses are even managing their own AI API connections. These cost components provide a foundation for analyzing operational expenses and measuring overall value in the next section.

sbb-itb-e1b05dc

Cost Analysis: AI vs Human Support

Running Costs

AI support is much cheaper to run compared to human agents. Human phone agents typically cost between $0.42 and $1.08 per minute, while AI solutions range from just $0.09 to $0.29 per minute. Here’s a quick look at some options in the market:

Provider Cost per Minute Features
Synthflow $0.08 No-code interface, context handling
Bland AI $0.09 Voice assistant tools
Vapi $0.10 Full feature set

The difference becomes even clearer when looking at problem resolution costs. Human agents cost anywhere from $5 to $35 per call, while virtual agents can handle the same interactions for less than $0.50.

Setup vs Hiring Costs

While ongoing costs are lower for AI, the initial investment varies significantly depending on the solution type. Businesses opting for AI can expect:

  • Pre-built solutions: $20 to $500 per month in subscription fees
  • Custom-built systems: $3,000 to $100,000 as a one-time cost

On the other hand, hiring human staff involves more than just salaries. Recruitment, training, and equipment costs add up, making it a larger long-term financial commitment. Beyond these upfront expenses, the speed and efficiency of AI further highlight its cost-effectiveness.

Speed and Output Metrics

AI systems excel at managing routine tasks with speed and precision. Virtual agents can deliver a 95% accuracy rate in responses and handle multiple conversations at once. This allows them to tackle large volumes of inquiries without the fatigue or inconsistency that can affect human teams.

Platforms like Converso showcase this efficiency by automating first-line support across various channels. This frees up human agents to focus on more complex issues that require emotional understanding and advanced problem-solving. Such systems demonstrate how AI can combine lower costs with high performance.

Mixed AI-Human Support Model

Combining the strengths of AI and human support, a blended model improves both efficiency and service quality. With AI managing routine inquiries, productivity can increase by 2–3×. In fact, 43% of businesses are now investing in AI to improve support operations. This approach allows human agents to focus on more complex tasks, streamlining processes and cutting costs. Platforms that merge AI's speed with human judgment showcase the effectiveness of this model.

Converso Platform Capabilities

Converso

Converso is a prime example of a hybrid support system in action. Aaron Valente, Director at Key Health Partnership, highlighted how Converso's integration reduced insurance policy inquiries by over 50% while opening doors for lead generation.

"Converso's AI helpdesk has reduced the volume of insurance policy queries that the support team answer by at least 50%, through easy integration of our AI Agent with our human agents. Together with a future use for lead gen, it has the potential to revolutionize our business!"

Here’s what makes the Converso platform stand out:

  • Multi-Channel Integration: It consolidates communications from platforms like WhatsApp, SMS, and webchat into a single inbox, making teamwork more seamless.
  • Automated First-Line Support: AI agents handle initial customer interactions and common questions, lightening the load for human agents and allowing them to focus on more specialized issues.
  • Smart Workflow Management: With features like dedicated workspaces and automated routing, the platform ensures customer inquiries are handled quickly and efficiently.

Conclusion

Cost analysis shows clear advantages for a hybrid AI-human model. Inefficient communication costs employers around $10,200 per worker each year, while AI-driven tools can automate up to 80% of repetitive IT support tasks. This reduces support costs, with traditional support averaging $17.19 per voice ticket and $15.72 per chat interaction.

For example, GitHub's AI assistant resolved 60% of support cases in under 7 minutes, and Thrasio's adoption of AI solutions saved close to $2 million while cutting resolution times in half. These examples highlight AI's ability to boost efficiency in support operations.

A hybrid model combines AI's speed with human expertise. John Wang, co-founder at Assembled, explains:

"Even the leading AI companies still use human agents for their own support. The key insight isn't replacing humans, but transforming how they work. We're focused on identifying which tasks AI should handle, how to escalate effectively, and where human expertise adds the most value".

This perspective aligns with earlier findings on cost savings and operational improvements. Platforms like Converso show how hybrid systems can work in practice. By automating first-line support and ensuring smooth transitions to human agents, they improve both cost efficiency and service quality. Converso's multi-channel capabilities and workflow automation tools provide a strong foundation for updating customer support processes.

The balance between AI-driven efficiency and human insight is shaping the future of customer support, offering reduced costs and better experiences.

Related Blog Posts

March 31, 2025
March 31, 2025

How to Improve AI Agent Accuracy

read article
March 24, 2025
March 24, 2025

Step-by-Step Guide to CRM API Integration

read article
March 17, 2025
March 17, 2025

AI-Human Collaboration: Best Practices for Helpdesks

read article
March 10, 2025
March 10, 2025

How AI Automation Scales Support, Saves Money

read article